The Legacy of "Mother" Lee

F rances Glessner Lee was credited with many distinguished honors during her eighty-five years, including, creator of Harvard’s department of legal medicine; donor of more than a thousand books to the George Burgess Magrath Library of Legal Medicine; namesake of the Frances G. Lee Chair in Legal Medicine; and founder the Harvard Seminars in Homicide Investigation. She is honored as the founder of the Harvard Associated in Police Science (HAPS).1

HAPS Seminar 1955
Courtesy of The Glessner House Museum
Lee, seen here with a class from 1955 served as the first president and secretary-treasurer of HAPS.

She was the first female police captain for New Hampshire state police and the first woman to be invited to into the International Association for Chiefs of Police.2

Humbly, she often referred to herself as a "hobbyist." It would be easy to pigeonhole her as the stereotypical rich eccentric indulging in a twisted compulsion to play with and murder dolls.

However, the men she taught believed otherwise. "Mrs. Lee was unquestionably one of the world's most astute criminologists. She was acquainted with and respected by top criminologists all over the world."3

Frances Glessner Lee died in 1962. The Harvard Department of Legal Medicine closed in 1967 for financial reasons. The then Chief Medical Examiner of Maryland arranged for the Nutshell Studies to be moved to Baltimore where they are on permanent loan.

The Nutshells were restored in 1992 for $50,000 and are still used during the twice-yearly HAPS seminars to train investigators from around the country. They are not accessible to the public.

The Medical Examiner System

Coroners, with few exceptions are elected lay persons who rely on other medical personnel to assist in investigations and perform autopsies. Medical examiners are usually physicians and pathologists who are appointed and have been trained in medico-legal death investigation and forensic autopsies.4

I didn’t do a lick of work to deserve what I have. Therefore, I feel I have been left an obligation to do something that will benefit everybody.
-Frances Glessner Lee

Because coroners are elected, they can hold any profession—plumbers, barbers, undertakers, lawyers. Beginning in 1877 and riding the wave of medical professionalism, certain doctors began a movement to replace the coroner with the highly trained medical examiner. Massachusetts, and by extension Harvard University, seemed to be at the forefront of this movement.5

"It’s not necessary for him [the coroner] to know a tibia from a tuba, a choked drain from a choked windpipe. The only skilled knowledge he may have is how to play ball with the local political bosses."6

Harvard medical professors were vocal supporters of this push toward professionally trained medical examiners. Beginning in 1877, F.W Draper, a Harvard professor and president of the Massachussetts Medico-Legal Society taught Harvard's first course on the subject. Frances' endowment in the 1930s codified this move at Harvard with an entire department. The first two deparment chairs, George Burgess Magrath and Dr. Alan Moritz, respectively, were vocal supporters as well. Frances Glessner Lee and her Nutshell Studies became intertwined with this movement.7

Frances adjusts a corpse
Courtesy of The Glessner House Museum
Lee, adjusts the body of Maggie Wilson in the Dark Bathroom using dental tools.

Her program at Harvard to train medical examiners, coupled with her Harvard Associates in Police Science seminars, which focused on training the investigators and the seminars’ prominent use of the models seemed appropriately timed to illuminate the importance of the proper handling of medical evidence.

Nutshells and the 'CSI Effect'

It's hard to imagine a time when doctors and law enforcement had to fight for the use of forensics and pathology. We live in a world where anyone can become an amateur sleuth, just by watching television or reading any one of a plethora of mystery novels. Many popular television dramas gain incredible ratings by focusing on the use of science and technology in crime investigations. CSI: Crime Scene Investigation has been called "the most popular television show in the world" and has spun off countless television shows focusing on the same subject matter.8 As such, millions of people are now obliquely informed of forensics and its uses, a fact which has its own pros and cons.

"Two of a number of hypotheses loosely referred to as the 'CSI Effect' suggest that the television program and its spin-offs, which wildly exaggerate and glorify forensic science, affect the public, and in turn affect trials either by (a)burdening the prosecution by creating greater expectations about forensic science than can be delivered or (b) burdening the defense by creating exaggerated faith in the capabilities and reliability of the forensic sciences."9

Perhaps another result of the CSI Effect, the Nutshell Studies have seen a resurgence of interest in American popular culture. Our national obsession with forensics is the topic of a recently-filmed documentary which prominently highlights the Nutshells, and Corinne May Botz, a photographer, produced a coffee table book which includes all eighteen of the Nutshells and essays from her own research and family interviews.

Nutshells at the Medical Examiner's office in Maryland.
The Nutshells have been curated with special viewing panels in one room at the Baltimore Medical Examiner's office.

Additionally, Thomas Mauriello, a professor of Criminology and Criminal Justice at the University of Maryland, College Park teaches his students with his own custom-made dioramas.10

"Although few people today, even in forensic science, know about Frances Glessner Lee, her legacy lives on in those who teach via diorama, and even in a series of CSI episodes that used miniature crime scenes as clues in a serial killer investigation."11

In our high-tech world of luminol, DNA, computer modeling and CSI, these dioramas may seem like a very low-tech option. Yet, the fact that a modern teacher of criminal justice opts to use his own speaks volumes about her legacy.

1 "A Look At A Wonderful Lady: HAPS Founder, Frances Glessner Lee," pamphlet published by the Harvard Associates in Police Science, 1991.

2 Katherine Ramsland, "The Truth in a Nutshell: The Legacy of Frances Glessner Lee," The Forensic Examiner (Summer 2008) 20.

3 Earl Banner, "She Invested a Fortune in Police, Entertained them Royally at Ritz,"The Boston Sunday Globe, 4 February 1962.

4 Randy Hanzlick, MD & Debra Combs, MPH, "Medical Examiner and Coroner Systems: History and Trends," Journal of the American Medical Association (March 18,1998--Vol. 279, No. 11) 870.

5 James C. Mohr, Doctors and the Law: Medical Jurisprudence in Nineteenth-Century America, (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press) 1993, 244. Mohr offers an extensive discussion of Harvard's cirriculum, including a discussion of a private donor's wish to "emphasize the medicolegal investigation of death." This donor was undoubtedly Mrs. Lee, although Mohr does not name her.

6 Pete Martin, "How Murderers Beat the Law," The Saturday Evening Post, 10 December 1949.

7 Pete Martin, "How Murderers Beat the Law," and Mohr, Doctors and the Law.

8 Honorable Donald E. Shelton, "The 'CSI Effect' Does It Really Exist?" NIJ Journal (No. 259), available at http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/221501.pdf.

9 N.J. Schweitzer and Michael J. Saks, "The 'CSI Effect': Popular Fiction About Forensic Science Affects The Public's Expectations About Real Forensic Science," Jurimetrics (Spring 2007) 357-364, available at http://www.public.asu.edu/~nschwei/archive/csieffect.pdf.

10 Thomas P. Mauriello, The Dollhouse Murders: A Forensic Expert Investigates 6 Little Crimes, (New York: Pi Press) 2004.

11 Ramsland, "The Truth in a Nutshell," 20.